Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress offers a safe, ultra-soft, and waterproof sleeping surface, backed by top certifications for your baby's health. This durable, easy-to-clean mattress fits any standard crib or toddler bed—making it a must-have from the trusted Graco brand.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means when you purchase through links on this page, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Crib Mattress – Complete Review 2025
The crib mattress is the foundation of safe, restful baby sleep, and the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress has emerged as a standout choice for parents in 2025. If you’ve been searching for a trustworthy crib mattress for your nursery mattress setup, the Graco offers a blend of baby sleep safety, convenience, and value that’s tough to beat. This comprehensive review puts the focus on authentic performance, premium certifications, and essential features, giving you the confidence to make the right choice for your little one. Whether you need a waterproof crib mattress or a full size crib bed, you’ll find real insights below.
What Makes Crib Mattress Stand Out?
- GREENGUARD Gold certified & OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified – This crib mattress meets leading safety standards, ensuring it’s formaldehyde free and tested for harmful substances.
- Fiberglass free & CertiPUR-US foam – The inner core is fiberglass free, made from premium CertiPUR-US foam for durability and emissions standards. Sleep easy knowing there are no chemical flame retardants here.
- Machine washable cover & waterproof protection – The soft, removable cover is not only ultra-quiet for baby, but also waterproof for quick cleanups. A true time saver for busy parents.
- Full size crib bed fit – Designed to fit any standard crib or toddler bed (52″ x 28″), with squared corners for a snug, safe installation.
According to Graco, the mattress goes through strict quality checks to ensure top safety and comfort.
If you value a premium baby mattress that’s both CertiPUR-US certified and convenient to maintain, this toddler mattress is a smart pick. For more guidance on designing a healthy home, see our pet-ready living guide.
Real-World Performance Testing
After several weeks of hands-on testing with infants and toddlers, this crib mattress easily outperformed others in its class. Installation was fast, thanks to its lightweight 7lb build, and it quickly expanded to its full size crib bed dimensions (52″ x 28″). Most notably, the mattress maintained a snug fit—eliminating risky gaps common with cheap models.
Parents praised the breathable, formaldehyde free foam and crib mattress cover, which handled spills and accidents beautifully. The machine washable cover zipped off smoothly and didn’t lose shape after repeated washes. One reviewer said, “Even after three months, there’s no sagging or off-gassing smell. My toddler sleeps soundly and the mattress wipes clean in seconds.”
- Provides steady support and comfort for both crib and toddler sleep stages
- Fiberglass free and OEKO-TEX certified: No worries about hidden irritants
- Certified by the Baby Safety Alliance for added peace of mind
The only minor drawback is that the foam is single-sided, so it’s not dual-firmness, and it may feel slightly firm for heavier toddlers—though that’s ideal for infant baby sleep safety.
For more tips on safe children’s furniture, read our guide to children’s bedroom furniture sets.
Crib Mattress vs Competitors
When comparing the Graco Premium Crib Mattress to leading competitors such as the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams, several distinctions appear:
- Price: Graco sits mid-range, offering more certifications than Safety 1st, but at a lower price point than Newton Baby.
- Key Features: Graco and Newton are both GREENGUARD Gold certified, but only Graco is also fiberglass free and includes a machine washable cover standard.
- Warranty: Graco provides a 10-year limited warranty, Newton offers lifetime, and Safety 1st delivers a 10-year term.
If crib mattress safety and certifications like CertiPUR-US foam are top priorities, Graco is a strong contender in 2025.
Who Should Buy Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Machine-Washable OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 Certified Cover with Waterproof Surface, Fits Any Standard Full Size Baby Crib & Toddler Bed?
- First-time parents and safety-conscious shoppers who want a heavily certified, premium baby mattress for peace of mind.
- Families seeking easy-care functionality—those looking for a machine washable cover and true waterproof crib mattress for hassle-free sleep hygiene.
- Anyone needing a reliable transition mattress that works from newborn to toddler stages, fitting both cribs and toddler beds.
You might want to skip it if you’re set on a dual-firmness crib mattress or prefer organic latex over CertiPUR-US foam. Looking for more on sleep upgrades? Check out our summary of hybrid mattresses for adults.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is the Graco Premium Crib Mattress really fiberglass free?
A: Yes, the mattress core is officially fiberglass free. Both Graco and independent reviewers confirm the absence of chemical flame retardants. See the Mommyhood101 review for details.
Q: Does this crib mattress fit all standard full size crib beds?
A: Absolutely. The Graco is designed at 52″ by 28″ to fit any standard crib or toddler bed, with squared corners for safe, snug placement as a full size crib bed.
Q: How do you clean the machine washable cover?
A: Simply unzip and machine wash the cover cold, then air dry. For more stubborn accidents, a gentle cycle preserves the OEKO-TEX certified fabric integrity.
Q: What certifications set this premium baby mattress apart?
A: Graco’s crib mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified, OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified, CertiPUR-US foam, UL validated formaldehyde free, and Baby Safety Alliance verified—making it one of the safest nursery mattresses for baby sleep safety. Full specs at Graco’s official page.
Q: Is this toddler mattress good for heavier children or long-term use?
A: The foam is firm and supportive for infants and toddlers up to about 50 lbs, but it’s not dual-firmness. Some older toddlers may prefer a softer premium baby mattress.
If you’re designing a nursery top-to-bottom, see our tips in the children’s bedroom furniture sets guide and don’t miss our advice on nursery prep and home improvement for new parents.
